Social media should not feel like a slot machine. You should know what is going out, when it is going out, and what you are getting in return. Yet for many brands, feeds feel noisy, random, and late, while meetings about content seem endless.
Right now platforms, formats, and algorithms change quicker than most teams can react. One week it is short vertical video, the next week it is long-form, carousels or something new on a different app. When the rules change that fast, loose plans and vague support turn into chaos, not growth.
The real issue is simple: most businesses are still buying hours, retainers and woolly “support”. They are not buying clear output or clear outcomes. What brands actually want is not another presentation, but consistent, on-brand content that ships on time and actually moves numbers that matter.
The old agency model was built for a slower internet. Big scopes, huge decks, nine-week approval chains. Socials now needs speed and rhythm. A social media management subscription, with fixed output and fixed expectations, is a far better fit for how platforms work today. That is exactly the space we choose to play in.
How Legacy Agencies Quietly Profit From Confusion
Legacy agencies rarely say “we profit from chaos”, but watch how the model plays out. You get a retainer, then add-on fees the moment you ask for “just a few extra posts”. You sit in meeting after meeting while your feed sits empty.
Common signs of this confusion model are easy to spot:
Confusing retainers that bundle lots of vague “strategic time”
Extra charges every time you want more posts or new formats
Opaque reports that look pretty but hide what was actually delivered
Endless decks explaining why next month will be different
When hours are the product, the incentive is to create more hours. That means more complexity, more “work in progress”, more people touching a single post. Some brands wait weeks for a tiny update, while copy passes through layers of approvals and design is billed twice under different line items.
There may be quarterly “creative refresh” projects that mostly exist to justify the retainer. In a world where marketing budgets are under pressure and boards want clear answers, it is hard to defend paying for fog. Brands cannot afford to bankroll inefficiency just to keep an agency busy.
Why Your Brand Needs a Product, Not a Promise
Social media does not need another promise; it needs a product. A product is simple: this is what you get, this is what it costs, this is when it arrives. No drama.
A social media management subscription flips the model. Instead of woolly scopes and “best efforts”, you get a defined output, for example 20 posts each month, for a clear price. That gives brand leaders:
Fewer surprises when month’s end comes
Easier budget planning across channels and campaigns
Simple maths on cost per post, per campaign or per channel
A real sense of value, not guesswork
For us at Kraken, the product is the point. Strategy, design, copywriting and scheduling are baked into one subscription, not sliced up as extras. The work you actually need to see on your feed is the work that is included.
There is also a quiet psychological shift. When you buy hours, it is hard to quit, because sunk cost guilt kicks in. When you buy a product, accountability is clear. Either the content turns up at the quality you were promised, or you cancel. No hostages, no drama.
Inside a No-Nonsense Social Media Management Subscription
So what does a no-nonsense subscription look like in real life? Strip away the jargon, and it is very simple: one fixed, transparent setup for 20 posts each month, covering strategy, creative, copy and scheduling.
The monthly rhythm usually looks like this:
A quick strategy sprint at the start to set themes and angles
Fast content planning that maps posts to dates and channels
Tight design and copy cycles so ideas turn into assets quickly
Scheduling ahead of time so content is ready before it is needed
The goal is speed without sloppiness. Content should ship in days, not weeks. Approvals should be simple, not an obstacle course. When platforms add a new feature, you should be able to respond without going back to scope, contracts or long budget talks.
As calendars fill with events, launches and holidays, this fixed content capacity really helps. You know you have a set amount of high-quality social output ready each month. No more last-minute scrambles to post something “just so the feed is not empty”, especially when the weather is gloomy, everyone is busy and your team’s focus is pulled in ten directions.
Outcomes That Actually Matter to Your Bottom Line
Too many social reports still obsess over vanity metrics. Reach, impressions and views can be helpful, but they are not the whole story. If we are honest, most leadership teams care about a much shorter list.
A serious social media management subscription should focus on outcomes like:
Quality engagement, not random likes
Website visits from the right audiences
Leads, sign-ups and enquiries that your team can act on
Sales uplift that can be linked back to social campaigns
When your output is consistent in both volume and quality, you finally have a fair test. You are not guessing which post worked from two posts a month. You have enough data to see patterns, run simple experiments and make smart creative calls.
At Kraken, we build in content testing as part of the flow. Posts are not one-off bets, they are steps in a learning loop. Creative is updated using real results, and reporting is kept sharp and simple so the C-suite can skim it while marketers get the detail they need. The real impact comes month after month, not from one noisy “big campaign” followed by silence.
Fire the Chaos and Test a Challenger Instead
If your social spend is buying confusion, you are allowed to walk away from it. You do not need another 12-month retainer that cannot tell you exactly what you will get each month. You can demand fixed, outcome-focused offers instead.
A simple place to start is a quick audit. Look at the last 90 days with your current setup and ask:
How many posts actually went live, on each channel?
How long did it take to get one idea from brief to publish?
What did you really pay per post, once all fees are counted?
Which outcomes can you clearly link to that activity?
Then, instead of blowing everything up, move a portion of your social budget into a lean, fixed-price challenger model like ours at Kraken. Run them side by side. Compare delivery speed, creative quality and impact on the numbers that matter to you.
If your social budget is not buying predictable, high-quality output and real outcomes, it is not a strategy, it is chaos. You do not have to keep funding that chaos. You can unsubscribe from it and choose something that actually ships.
Turn Your Daily Posting Into A Strategic Advantage
If you are ready to move beyond ad hoc posting and build a consistent, purposeful presence, our social media management subscription gives you a clear framework and expert support. At Kraken, we plan, create and refine your content so every post works harder for your brand. Share your goals with us and we will shape a practical roadmap tailored to your audience and sector. Let us handle the moving parts so you can focus on running your business with confidence.
Follow me to keep in touch
Where I share my creative journey, design experiments, and industry thoughts.
